英特尔 i3-10100 vs 9100 与 8100 – 超线程是否重要?
这给了我们在旧的 i3 9100 和 i3 8100 游戏和应用程序中的 CPU 让我们了解并了解它们如何比较. 所有三个处理器都拥有 4 核心. 然而, 只有最新的第 10 代 10100 有超线程的较旧 8100 和 9100 不要。. All three have the same amount of cache and same base clock speed. 然而, the maximum turbo speed increases with each generation. Im comparing these processors, because I think it will be interesting to see how the i3 has changed over time and also to look at the difference. Hyperthreading will make. 在价格差异方面. 该 10100 似乎去 140 美元 75 USD for the 9100F, 而 8100 appears to be more expensive, probably as its older and harder to find.. There is also the F version of the 8100, 但那是, not what I have here. So you could probably save some money if you dont need the integrated graphics., All processors were tested in the same system, 然而, Ive had to change motherboards as the 10th gen uses. The new LGA1200 socket. 对于 8100 和 9100 Ive used the MSI Z'0 ACE and for the 10100 Ive used the MSI Z490 ACE., While none of these processors can be overclocked using these more expensive, motherboards does allow for faster memory.. 其余组件与 16gb DDR4 相同的 Ii 测试 3200 内存在 CL14 的双通道中运行，并且带有 Nvidia RTX 2080 Ti to reduce bottlenecks.
. 显然, this is not typical hardware youd match with an i3. The goal of this comparison is not to show you what youd expect with more real world hardware, but to instead to compare the processors.. It probably would have made more sense to test with slower memory. But I had this data for other comparisons and didnt want to test all three processors twice.. Although all chips came with a stock cooler, Ive done all testing. With my Fractal S36 AIO with Noctua NT H1 thermal paste. 测试已完成与最新版本的 Windows 和 Nvidia 驱动程序, along with all BIOS updates available installed.. 考虑到这一点, 以及, first check out the differences in various applications as well as power draw and thermals followed by gaming tests at 1080p and 1440p resolutions afterwards. Starting with Cinebench R20 Ive got the Intel i3 10100 processor at the top of the graph. The next level 9100F below in the middle, then the older 8100 down the bottom. Straight away. We can see the 10th gen i3 has the largest boost in multicore performance, owing to the fact that it has hyperthreading. Unlike the rest., This puts it 36 速度比 9100 和 54 速度比 8100. 我还测试了旧的Cinebench R15, 因为很多人仍然使用它, and the margins were quite similar to what we just saw with the newer R20. Blender was Tested with the Opendata, 宝马和教室基准。, 该 10100 was able to complete this task around 60, faster than the 8th, 根, 8100 要么 44 faster when compared to the 9th gen 9100.
So some nice gains there due to this being another highly threaded, workload. 手刹被用来将我的 4k 笔记本电脑评论视频之一转换为 1080p, 与 HQ 1080p30 预设，作为另一个程序，利用额外的线程. The i3 10100 was the fastest out of these options coming out 28 faster than the 9th gen i3 and 42 faster than the 8th gen i3.. Adobe Premiere 用于导出我的笔记本电脑评论之一. 4k 和我已经使用 Vbr 的视频 2 通过. So all were running for over an hour. 再次, 该 10100 was completing the task fastest, 如预期, putting it 26 faster than the 9100F or 40 faster when compared with the 8100. Premiere was also tested using the Puget systems benchmark tool and this test factors in more Than just export times such as live playback., 该 10100 was doing much better in these combined Premiere tests now scoring 42 faster than the 9100F and a massive 63 速度比 8100. So if youre, a video editor, the 10th gen option does offer some nice improvements. Ive used the Puget Systems Photoshop benchmark, and while there are modest improvements with the newer chips, the difference is less pronounced compared to other multicore heavy workloads.. 该 10100 得分 11 ahead of the 9100F and 21 之前 8100, 其中, while sounding good, is one of the lower results out of all applications. 测试. 7 Zip 用于测试压缩和解压缩速度, and the extra threads with the 10100 appear to be offering a significant boost over the other options.
AES encryption and decryption was tested using VeraCrypt, and this workload saw the largest improvement with the 10100 out of All applications tested with the 10100 more than 80 速度比 8100., V 射线基准, uses the CPU to render out a scene and as another multicore test, 该 10100 was scoring much higher over the other two i3 processors.. It was scoring 38 faster than the 9100F and 48 速度比 8100.. The Corona benchmark also uses the processor to render out a scene and as another threaded workload, 该 10100 was doing much better than the others completing the task 58 faster than the 9100F and 75 faster compared to the 8100. Ive used the Hardware Unboxed Microsoft Excel test And the i3 10100 was once more completing the task, the fastest, 几乎 50 faster over the 9100 and nearly 60 速度比 8100. 吉克本 5 was seeing one of the lower differences in the multicore score when compared to the other threaded workloads, 虽然 10100 still Has a 20 至 30 lead over the others in multicore score, and while the single core scores are higher too, this was the lowest improvement seen to single core performance out of all apps tested.. These are the differences between the Intel i3 10100 against the i3 9100F. From last generation., 我们可以看到, results can really vary based on the specific workload. 然而, 该 10100 was ahead in all cases, 这是有道理的, given its got double the thread count and a 100Mhz higher turbo boost, 速度.
Heres how the 10100 compares against the older 8100F from the 8th generation as the 8100 is clocked a fair bit lower without turbo Boost speeds: the differences are much larger compared to what we just saw with the 9100. 继承人, how much faster the 9100F is in these same tests over the 8100 Ive left, the X Axis scale the same to the last two graphs shown, as this really shows how Much more of an improvement: 该 10100 is offering.. When we look at the total system power draw from the wall in the blender test, 该 8100 was using the least amount of power as youd expect. 然而, I found it very interesting that the 10100 was using less compared to the 9100F.. The 10th gen option must be a fair bit more efficient because, while using less power, its completing this task around 44 比 9100F 快. 作为 10100 is using less power than the 9100F. Its not too surprising to see it also running a little cooler as well, though the 8100F was cooler still granted. These temps under heavy blender load are no issues at all. With my way, overkill AIO, 我怀疑, theyd, be fine with their stock coolers too.. These are the clock, speeds that were reached over all cores.. All three of these options had no issues running at their maximum. All core speeds. 让我们进入游戏结果. 下一个我测试 15 游戏在1080p和1440p分辨率.
. 作为提醒， 我使用 Rtx 2080 Ti 减少 GPU 瓶颈, the goal of these numbers is not to show you what sort of frame rates to expect from these processors, with more reasonable GPUs its to compare the processors against each other in an unconstrained. Manner. 战场V测试运行通过游戏的同一部分在战役中. 模式. Ive got the 1080p results down the bottom. The 1440p results above. 在 1080p. There wasnt too much of a boost in average FPS, 而 1 low was about the same on the 9th and 10th gen chips. 在 1440p. The averages are much closer together, 虽然 1 low continued, improving the newer, 处理器. 刺客, Creed Odyssey was tested with the games benchmark tool and as a test that Ive noted to be fairly CPU dependent in the past. 该 10100 was seeing massive gains. 在 1080p. 甚至其 1 low was above the average frame rate from the 9100F.. 该 10100 是 36 faster in average FPS over the 9100F at 1080p and 1440p, 然后一个更大的 51 速度比 8100 在1080p和 45 更快在 1440p. 使命召唤. Modern warfare was tested in campaign mode and at 1080p the results were a little inconsistent as seen by the 9100F coming in a little behind the 8100.. This was also noted in the 1 low performance at 1440p. 然而, this time the average FPS was ahead of the 8100, but either way there are no major differences in this game.
Between these three i3 processors. 边疆, 3 测试使用内置于基准的游戏. 再次, not too much of a difference in terms of average FPS, 虽然 1 lows were a little odd, with the 9100F seemingly doing better there at 1440p, but then about the same As the 8100 在 1080p. Control was tested by performing the same test pass through the game on all three test. Systems. 在 1080p, the average frame rate was very close, regardless of processor used. 然而, 该 1 low was improving more as we step up through from oldest to newest. 红色死亡. 救 赎 2 测试使用游戏基准工具, and this test saw big gains from the 10th gen processor. 在 1080p. 该 10100 是 49 速度比 8100 和 33 比 9100F 快. Then at 1440p the 10100 是 36 速度比 8100 和 22 比 9100F 快. So less of a difference at the higher resolution as the processor typically matters less there.. 古墓丽影的阴影也测试与游戏基准工具, and there were also some fair improvements. Seen with the newer processors. 在 1080p, 该 10100 是 18 faster than the 9100F just below it, 但 29.5 更快. When compared to the oldest 8100. 彩虹六围测试使用内置基准与Vulkan。. There was minimal difference to the averages at 1440p, 虽然. A bit more of a difference seen in the 1 低位.
在 1080p, where the processor often matters more though the 10100 是 17 faster than the 8th gen, 8100 和 11.5 faster than the 9th gen 9100F. Fortnite was tested using the replay feature with the exact same Replay file run on all three processors. 在 1440p, the average FPS was similar. 然而, there were nice gains to 1 低性能. As we move up the stack to the newer options. 在 1080p, the averages were a little more different. But again the big difference was in the 1 低, 其中 10100 是 45 比 9100F 快. 在这方面. CSGO was tested using the Ulletical FPS benchmark and as a game thats typically sensitive to processor performance. 该 10100 was doing best as expected. 在练习范围内测试了监督, 虽然这运行比实际的游戏更好, it more easily allows me to perform. The exact same test run, 这是理想的比较， 像这样. 在 1080p, were basically hitting the 300 FPS frame cap with the 10th gen i3. 然而, theres a much larger 20 improvement seen in the 1 低。, 该司 2 was tested using the games benchmark tool and with the 1080p resolution the 10100 had the biggest improvement out of all 15 游戏测试. 在 1080p. 它是 61 速度比 8100 和 49 比 9100F 快, so some big gains that must be down to hyperthreading.. 巫师 3 was tested running through the same section of the game and as a game that tends to be more GPU heavy, especially at this setting level.
There wasnt too big of a difference between the processors, though it was strange that the 10th gen had consistently lower 1 低点为 1080p, but was then back on top at 1440p., Ghost Recon Breakpoint was tested with the games built in benchmark, and this was another title Where the 1 low performance with the 10100 had a significant improvement when compared to the other processors, presumably due to the extra thread count. 远哭. New Dawn was also tested with the games built in benchmark and although the improvements were less compared to some of the others, there were still consistent gains as we move up through 8th to 10th gen. 平均. Out of these 15 游戏测试, the Intel i3 10100 是 14 faster at 1080p in average FPS when compared against the older i3 9100F processor.. Some games, 喜欢控制, saw basically no difference, while others like the division. 2, were almost reaching 50 higher frame rates.. When we step up to the 1440p resolution, 虽然, the difference lowers to a 7 lead with the 10th gen processor, as the CPU, typically matters less at higher resolutions like this., When we compare the 10100 against the older 8th gen i3 8100 at 1080p theres. A much larger 21 提升至平均 Fps, but again results can really vary by specific game.. Once more control saw basically no difference. While again, the Division 2 有一个巨大的 61 改进. 在 1440p. 再次, the difference is less pronounced.
然而, the 10th gen chip was still able to achieve a fairly decent 12 higher average frame rate on average. 有, much less of a difference. When we look at how the 9100F compares with the 8100. 在 1080p, the 9100F was less than 6 更快. While this lowers to around 4 在 1440p, which I think really helps illustrate how much extra performance is on offer from the addition of hyperthreading. 是啊, the extra clockspeed would be helping a bit too but its nice to have this here.. 当我们考虑成本时, the 10th gen 10100 doesnt appear to be great value at the moment., Its going for around 140 纽蛋的美元, and I cant see it at that many other stores, presumably due to low supply, as is the case with many Other 10th gen processors at the moment.. This puts it almost twice as expensive as the 9100F and while theres an argument for the performance boost in productivity workloads its difficult to justify when it comes to gaming, 给定 10100 是 14 faster than the 9100F on average.. 真, based on what we saw in my 3300X vs 10100 video previously, the 3300X seems like much better value as its cheaper offers. A similar experience in many games, but comes out even further ahead in productivity workloads.. It would seem that Intel were forced to introduce hyperthreading to the i3 lineup by AMD as the Ryzen 3, 3100 and 3300X. Both offer 4 内核和 8 threads for less to similar price points.
, Regardless of which you pick. 我们, as consumers are winning here by having more options available, which is good to see.. Based on all of this information, let me know which i3 youd pick and why? Down in the comments, assuming, 答案是肯定的, youre planning on going for an i3 Dont, forget that if you already have a 8100 要么 9100, you need to upgrade the motherboard to use 10th gen.. 否则, 如果你的新频道, then get subscribed for more processor comparisons and tech.