AMD 锐曾 5 3600 vs 3600X – X 值得额外的钱?
But what are the differences between them and is it worth paying more for the X In this detailed comparison? 好, look at the differences in games and applications both at stock and while overclocked, to help you decide which to get. Lets start out with the specs.. Both CPUs have 6 内核和 12 threads are unlocked and have the same amount of cache.. As for the differences, the 3600X has higher base and boost clock speeds and is listed with a higher TDP.. 两个 CPU 都在同一系统中进行测试, so the only difference was the CPUs and their coolers.. Both CPUs were tested with the Asrock Taichi X570 motherboard, 16gb DDR4 3200 CL14 在双通道运行的内存, 与Nvidia RTX 2080 钛. Ive tested both CPUs with the stock coolers that they come with in the box, as well as the thermal paste That comes pre applied, as I figure most people will probably end up using these.. 该 3600 comes with the Wraith Stealth and the 3600X comes with the larger Wraith Spire.. This difference in cooling capacity also seems to be why the X model is listed with a higher TDP as well see its not actually that much more powerful. 测试已使用同一版本的 Windows 完成, 每个 CPU 的 Nvidia 驱动程序和 BIOS, all of which were The latest available version at the time of testing. Ive tested both CPUs at stock and overclocked.. I managed to get my 3600 至 4.
1GHz and the 3600X to 4.2GHz, but this was a limitation of the coolers. Ive been able to get my 3600 to 4.2GHz with an AIO in the past. But as youll see later, the temperatures get quite high with the smaller cooler, which is why the max overclock was 100MHz less.. 考虑到这一点, 以及, 首先查看各种应用中的差异, 以及功耗和散热, 随后以 1080p 和 1440p 分辨率进行游戏测试. 之后, then finish up by comparing some performance per dollar. Metrics. 让我们从 Cinebench R20 开始. Ive got the overclocked results on the upper half of the graph, while the stock results are on the lower half.. 如预期的那样, the 3600X is coming out ahead due to those higher clock. 速度。, As both CPUs have the same core count, though theres not too big, of a difference. 库存. The 3600X was around 5 速度比 3600, both in single and multicore performance.. 一旦两者都超频, though this lowers to just a 2 导致. 它的价值, noting that the single core results are lower with the overclocks applied on both CPUs. This is because manually overclocking, 所有 6 cores to the same speed is actually lower than what both can boost to out of the box in single core workloads., 虽然 Cinebench R15 已被刚刚覆盖的较新的 R20 所取代, I wanted to also include the results of This one too, as many other people, are still using it, and that may allow you to compare my results.
At stock theres, a similar 5 gain to single core performance. Just like in R20, 虽然, multicore was only 3 ahead with the 3600X., 一旦两者都超频, the gap closes in with both single and multicore scores. On the 3600X, no more than 2 之前 3600. Again weve got lower single core performance when manually overclocked. As this prevents, the higher boosts speeds that can be hit in single core workloads. Ive tested Blender with the BMW and Classroom benchmarks, and this is a test that works better with more cores. As weve got the same core count, theres only a small difference due to The clock, speed changes. At default stock speeds. The 3600X was completing both tasks 4.5 速度比 3600. 然而, once both are overclocked, the 3600X is only around 2 提前. 手刹用于将 4K 文件转换为 1080p，然后将不同的 1080p 文件转换为 720p。. 这是另一个从更多线程中获益的工作负载, so the results are pretty close together, as both CPUs have the same 6 核心 12 线程. 库存. The 4K task completed just 3.7 faster on the 3600X and 2.6 faster for the 1080p task.. When overclocked the difference dropped to 2.1 和 1.6 分别, so hardly any real difference between these two chips. Adobe Premiere was used to export. One of my laptop review videos at 1080p and the results between the two CPUs were again very close here.. The 3600X was completing the export 3.
6 速度比 3600 at stock speeds, 降为 2.2 faster export time, with both processors, 超频. 我还在 Adobe Premiere 中测试了扭曲稳定器效果. 基本上, 这将处理一个视频文件，使其平滑。. This is a single core workload and, as my manual all core overclocks, technically lower the single core boost speed, as we saw in the Cinebench results earlier, I havent bothered testing the manual overclocks as theyd just be worse. 在此测试中. The 3600X was 3.7 速度比 3600.. This is the first time Ive attempted to test Photoshop using the Puget Systems benchmark tool.. 该 3600 was seeing no major difference once overclocked and the 3600X actually got worse performance with the overclock applied. So not sure if some components of this test may favour single core performance, which my manual overclock will lower. 我已使用 7 用于测试压缩和解压速度的拉链. As another test that favours additional cores were again seeing close results, just small differences due to the clock. 速度. 库存, the 3600X is around 2 速度比 3600. 然后, when overclocked compression is only 0.3 更快, but decompression actually saw an increase to 3.2. VeraCrypt 用于测试 AES 加密和解密速度. 库存. Both were very close in encryption speeds margin of error difference realistically, while decryption saw a 5 higher speed with the 3600X.. This was another test where I didnt bother with overclocking, as in the past Ive found overclocking to produce strange results with this test, such as worse speeds.
. The V Ray benchmark is another multicore test that relies on thread count to boost performance and, as a result of both having the same core count and close clock speeds. The 3600X was 2.7 速度比 3600, both at stock and when overclocked. The Corona benchmark, uses the CPU to render out a scene and like most of these other applications is a multicore test. So there were no major differences.. The 3600X completed the render task 2.8. Faster than the 3600 at stock and 2.2, faster with both CPUs overclocked or in other words, from just 4 秒, faster to 3 seconds.. These are the differences between the 3600 and 3600X CPUs. 在所有这些应用中, 我们可以看到, results depend on the specific workload. 库存. In almost all of these tests, the 3600X was coming out ahead as expected, due to its higher clock, 速度. Single core performance tended to do better due to the different single core boost speeds of each chip.. Once we overclock both CPUs on all cores, the difference between the two CPUs narrows in a bit putting the 3600X just 2 速度比 3600 平均, so a pretty small difference and not really a good start for the X version. 伊夫. Also measured total system power draw from the wall while running the Blender benchmark. 库存. The 3600X was using 4.9 more power than the 3600, which almost scales with the 4.5 faster speed that it scored in this test.
两者均超频. The 3600X was now using 3.3. More power, but the difference in actual blender performance was closer to 2 现在。. 这些是运行相同混合器测试的 CPU 温度。, Both at stock and while overclocked the 3600X was significantly cooler.. My 4.1GHz overclock on the 3600 on the stock cooler was probably a bit optimistic, though it was perfectly stable under all of these tests.. The main reason the 3600X is running cooler despite performing better, is down to the coolers. The Wraith Spire that it comes with is just physically larger than the Wraith Stealth that comes with the 3600.. 如前所述, I couldnt push the 3600 any higher in blender due to thermal limitations with the stock cooler, but I could reach 4.2GHz with an AIO.. 所以, with a better cooler and both CPUs running at the same speed, Id expect no difference in performance.. These are the average clock speeds during the blender stress test, so overclocking the 3600 could get it to hit the same speeds as the stock 3600X, 虽然, due to the better cooling, the 3600X did occasionally boost up a little more. Anyway at stock. 该 3600 was on the warmer side, but still usable. If you want to overclock an aftermarket cooler might be worth looking into, though the results from the 3600X already show that theres not too much extra to gain.. This testing was, with the stock thermal paste that came pre applied to both coolers different paste could likely further improve performance.
让我们进入游戏结果. Next Ive tested these games at max settings at both 1080p and 1440p resolutions. 从股票结果开始. Then look at precision boost overdrive results, 之后. Shadow of the Tomb Raider was tested with the built in benchmark at highest settings.. 在所有即将推出的游戏图表中, Ive got the 1440p results shown on the upper half and 1080p results below.. 在此测试中. There was basically no practical difference: 只是 1 Fps, 无论哪种方式. Assassins Creed Odyssey was also tested with the built in benchmark at max settings.. 再次, the difference between the two was extremely small within 1 FPS in terms of average FPS and slightly higher differences for 1 低. 战场 5 was tested in campaign mode at ultra settings with the same test done on both CPUs.. The results are even closer here: 他们, essentially the same its too close to definitively say ones better than the other. 边疆 3 was tested with the built in benchmark at ultra settings., Again just a 1 FPS or so difference between these two CPUs. Nothing amazing going on here. Fortnite was tested with the replay feature and the same replay was used on each CPU., Although it appears theres a bigger difference, its just because the frame rate numbers are higher than the ones previously seen in terms of percentage change, 有. 基本上, 无差别. CSGO 已使用 ulletical Fps 基准进行测试, and I thought this one would be interesting. Given single threaded, CPU performance seems to matter more here compared to many other titles.
果然. 有一个 11 improvement to average FPS at 1080p with the 3600X, but as weve seen, this is the only game so far to see any sort of difference. Ive also tested out Rainbow. 六次围攻, with the built in benchmark., Like most of the other games, were back to seeing no noteworthy differences between the two CPUs. Weve also got the option of enabling PBO through the Ryzen Master software, with both CPUs. Ive retested Battlefield 5, and we can see just A tiny improvement over stock settings at 1080p, with both CPUs and due to this insignificant change, I havent bothered retesting all of the other games as its hardly making a meaningful difference. 这里. I also havent tested with manual overclocks, like I did with the multicore applications earlier. As Ive found, many games benefit more from PBO with Ryzen, as they still get to keep their higher single core boost, speeds.. 基本上, to summarize the gaming differences, there are no real differences; either CPU will perform essentially the same in games, so that just leaves us with the final difference. The price. 价格会随时间而变化. 您可以在描述中找到链接的更新价格. At the time of recording the Ryzen. 5 3600 is going for 200 美元, while getting that extra letter X and better cooler is going to cost an extra 35 要么 17.5 更多的钱, at least with the current sale. If youre paying the full MSRP of 250, 它的 25 更多的钱.
, These are the dollar per frame values at 1080p averaged out over all games tested.. 基本上, this just shows that the 3600 is better in terms of value, 它的 35 至 50, cheaper and, 正如我们所看到的, performed essentially the same as the 3600X for the most part. So this makes sense. 它不是所有关于游戏, though Ive also chosen Handbrake performance to compare, as this is a real world workload that scored about right on average out of all applications tested. In terms of value, 该 3600 is again winning.. The 3600X was performing 3.7. Better in this test, but if you buy it at the sale price, 它仍然 13 less value or over 20 more in terms of dollar per frame at the full MSRP., With both CPUs overclocked, the difference between them, doesnt really change, as the overclocks didnt make too Much difference., 该 3600 is still ahead in terms of value here, without sacrificing much performance at all.. That last sentence is basically the conclusion., Although the 3600X does perform slightly better out of the box, in particular, in terms of single core speeds. The extra price makes it difficult to justify compared to the 3600. 你, also getting the better stock cooler with the 3600X. But I dont think thats worth 35 至 50 USD when you could instead put that budget into an even better aftermarket option.. 所以, 总结, based on the current prices, I wouldnt consider buying the 3600X unless the prices were much closer together.
The small improvement in performance just doesnt seem to be worth it both when we look at it in terms of gaming or other productivity workloads.. Let me know which CPU youd pick and why? Down in the comments, 该 3600 or 3600X, and if the 3600X Im really keen to hear why its worth the extra money – or maybe it was just on a great sale, 在路上我得到了更多的 CPU 比较.